Table of Contents
Dinari receives first-ever US broker dealer license for tokenized stocks as regulatory landscape shifts under new SEC leadership toward blockchain-based capital markets.
Traditional stock ownership involves multiple intermediaries and antiquated settlement systems, but tokenized stocks promise instant settlement, 24/7 trading, and seamless crypto integration.
Key Takeaways
- Dinari secured the first US broker dealer license specifically for tokenized public stocks, marking regulatory milestone
- Traditional stock ownership involves complex chain of intermediaries: DTCC, clearing houses, broker dealers, and transfer agents
- Current "tokenized stocks" on platforms like XStocks are largely derivatives or IOUs, not actual stock ownership
- True tokenized stocks will maintain all rights including voting, dividends, and corporate actions while enabling DeFi features
- New SEC under Paul Atkins demonstrates openness to tokenized capital markets innovation compared to previous administration
- Regulatory approval requires state-by-state licensing beyond federal FINRA approval, creating implementation delays
- European markets already offer legitimate tokenized stocks through partnerships with companies like Gemini and Robinhood
- DeFi integration faces securities law constraints, requiring "DeFi on rails" approach with permissioned protocols
- Private company tokenization remains years away due to Regulation D transfer restrictions protecting exemption status
Understanding Traditional Stock Ownership Infrastructure
- Stock ownership involves multiple intermediaries creating complex settlement chain from individual investors to publicly traded companies
- DTCC (Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation) serves as central ledger for all US publicly traded securities, functioning as private company monopoly over critical financial infrastructure
- Broker dealers like Fidelity maintain customer accounts with direct ownership rights, unlike bank deposits where customers lack direct asset ownership
- Clearing houses such as Pershing provide liquidity pools and handle actual share acquisition from exchanges for broker dealers
- Transfer agents work directly with companies maintaining cap tables and coordinating with DTCC for shareholder voting and dividend distribution
- Settlement process requires T+1 timeframe for transaction completion, creating delays incompatible with modern digital finance expectations
The traditional system evolved from 1960s paper certificate model to electronic ledger system managed by private corporation. Gabriel Aught explained: "DTCC became a monopoly over time in a way that the government blessed effectively to keep track of" all securities ownership.
Regulatory Breakthrough: First Tokenized Stock License
- Dinari received first-ever US broker dealer license specifically authorizing tokenized public stock issuance after two-year FINRA approval process
- License covers National Market System (NMS) stocks including all NASDAQ and NYSE listed companies, not just private securities
- Federal approval requires additional state-by-state registration across all 50 states before operational launch, estimated 2-3 months per state
- Current license covers five states with 45 remaining, targeting end-of-year launch for full tokenized stock platform
- SEC demonstrated unprecedented cooperation including 28-person department demo reviewing compliance with securities laws
- Previous tokenized stock licenses focused only on private securities or digital securities, not publicly traded companies requiring DTCC integration
The licensing process required proving ability to maintain full securities law compliance while enabling blockchain functionality. As Aught noted: "We structured what we're going to offer that was consistent with the traditional securities laws" rather than attempting to circumvent existing regulations.
Current "Tokenized Stocks" Are Largely Derivatives
- XStocks and similar platforms offer price-tracking tokens rather than actual stock ownership, explicitly disclaiming equity rights
- These products suffer from significant price divergence from underlying assets due to limited liquidity pools worth only millions versus trillion-dollar capital markets
- Regulatory status remains questionable with platforms restricting access from US, EU, UK, Canada, and Australia due to securities law violations
- Robinhood's European tokenized stock offering represents legitimate one-to-one tracked products with proper regulatory compliance
- Gemini partnership with Dinari enables EU tokenized stock access through MiFID licensing framework allowing EU-wide operations
- Current platforms lack dividend rights, voting rights, and corporate action participation that define true stock ownership
The distinction between derivatives and actual tokenized stocks creates market confusion. Aught emphasized: "You're not actually buying the stock. They claim that it's one to one backed but it's not one to one tracked in the same way, right? Prices are diverging."
Benefits of True Tokenized Stocks
- Direct asset-to-asset swapping eliminates traditional sell-and-rebuy process requiring cash conversion and multi-day settlement
- Fractional ownership enables dollar-amount purchases rather than calculating specific share quantities
- 24/7 trading availability removes traditional market hour constraints and enables global accessibility
- Instant settlement eliminates T+1 delays enabling real-time portfolio rebalancing and risk management
- Cross-asset class trading allows seamless movement between crypto assets and traditional securities within single platform
- Self-custody options provide asset portability between platforms without lengthy transfer processes
- DeFi integration potential enables lending, borrowing, and yield generation using tokenized stocks as collateral
These benefits address fundamental inefficiencies in traditional capital markets. Aught observed: "People should try it. If they want to take $10,000 worth of Apple shares and sell it at Schwab, just wait to see how long that money actually lands in your account."
DeFi Integration Challenges and Solutions
- Direct DeFi integration violates securities laws requiring Know Your Customer (KYC) and Anti-Money Laundering (AML) compliance
- "DeFi on rails" approach enables DeFi features within permissioned environments maintaining regulatory compliance
- Atomic lending and borrowing against tokenized stocks becomes possible through controlled protocols with whitelisted participants
- Fully permissionless DeFi integration requires congressional action similar to stablecoin legislation rather than regulatory interpretation
- Coinbase and other exchanges developing whitelisted wallet systems enabling DeFi functionality within compliance frameworks
- Robinhood's layer 2 development suggests institutional approach to controlled DeFi environments for tokenized securities
The regulatory constraints create innovation opportunities within compliance boundaries. Aught explained: "We call it DeFi on rails" as pathway to bringing DeFi features to tokenized stocks without violating securities laws.
SEC Leadership Change Enables Innovation
- New SEC Chair Paul Atkins demonstrates openness to tokenized capital markets innovation compared to previous administration's hostility
- Commissioner Hester Peirce maintained consistent support for tokenized securities throughout regulatory transition
- SEC granted unprecedented access including 28-person department demo of Dinari's tokenized stock system
- Atkins publicly supported tokenized securities innovation during CNBC interview, marking significant policy shift
- Regulatory cooperation focuses on compliance verification rather than blanket opposition to blockchain-based securities
- Securities law changes require congressional action, but SEC interpretation enables significant innovation within existing framework
The regulatory environment transformation creates opportunities for compliant innovation. Aught noted: "Before this, the SEC wouldn't even grant us an audience" compared to current cooperative approach.
Private Company Tokenization Remains Distant
- Regulation D exemptions require transfer restrictions preventing real-time tokenized trading of private company shares
- Every share transfer requires board approval and specific investor qualification, making scalable tokenization impossible
- Private companies risk losing regulatory exemptions if they enable permissionless secondary trading
- Secondary market transactions occur through controlled processes like employee liquidity events rather than continuous trading
- Regulatory framework prioritizes investor protection over market accessibility for private securities
- Long-term solution requires comprehensive regulatory reform enabling public company formation without current compliance burdens
Private market tokenization faces structural regulatory barriers. Aught explained: "Every private company has a provision that basically says if you transfer your shares to somebody else, the company can invalidate your stocks."
Market Size and Timeline Projections
- Global publicly traded stock market represents $100-120 trillion with US comprising approximately $50 trillion
- Tokenized stock adoption timeline compared to stablecoin development suggests 8-12 year path to mainstream adoption
- Current stage resembles 2016-2017 stablecoin development with early recognition but limited infrastructure
- Billion-dollar tokenized stock market likely within 2-3 years with full regulatory compliance
- Ten-billion-dollar market possible within 5-7 years as institutional adoption accelerates
- Hundred-billion-dollar market represents inflection point toward traditional capital market displacement
The development timeline reflects regulatory complexity rather than technical challenges. Aught positioned current progress: "We have probably 2016 2017 something like that in stable coin terms" indicating early but accelerating adoption phase.
Common Questions
Q: What makes tokenized stocks different from traditional stocks?
A: Tokenized stocks maintain identical ownership rights while enabling instant settlement, 24/7 trading, and blockchain-based features.
Q: Are current "tokenized stocks" on platforms like XStocks legitimate?
A: Most current platforms offer derivatives or IOUs rather than actual stock ownership, with questionable regulatory status.
Q: When will US investors access true tokenized stocks?
A: Dinari targets end-of-year launch pending state-by-state licensing completion, with other providers following similar timelines.
Q: How do tokenized stocks integrate with DeFi?
A: Current integration requires "DeFi on rails" approach with permissioned protocols maintaining regulatory compliance.
Q: What regulatory changes enable tokenized stock innovation?
A: New SEC leadership demonstrates cooperation with compliant innovation while maintaining existing securities law framework.
Tokenized stocks represent the next evolution of capital markets infrastructure, bringing traditional securities onto blockchain platforms while maintaining regulatory compliance. The combination of regulatory approval, institutional adoption, and technological capability creates conditions for transformative change in how investors access and manage equity investments.
